Sunshine Realty

What Montague's For-Sale List Holds This Fall

Teak patio chairs overlook a fenced golden pasture and low foothills on a clear late-fall afternoon near Montague.

In October 2026, Montague's 96064 ZIP code had about 112 active listings. Yreka had about 111. Sales tell a different story. Montague closed 8 home sales in October and Yreka closed 27. If you divide Montague's full listing count by its October sales, you get about 14 months of supply. That number would describe a stalled market, and the market isn't stalled.

The gap comes from what the 112 listings actually are. Most of them are vacant land. The home market is much smaller, and it moves more steadily than the headline count suggests. If you're comparing the two towns, sort Montague's inventory by type before you read any other number.

Most of the 112 listings are vacant land

In mid-November 2026, the major search sites returned between 61 and 72 vacant land listings for 96064, depending on the site and its filter. The same searches returned 31 to 35 single-family homes and 6 to 8 manufactured homes. Two farm and ranch listings with Montague addresses sat at the top of the range, one asking $1,199,000 and one pending at $1,250,000.

So someone shopping for a house in Montague is choosing from roughly 40 homes, not 112. Against 8 October sales, that works out to about five months of supply. Yreka's 111 listings against 27 sales come to about four months. Measured house to house, the two towns are much closer than the headline counts make them look.

The land side is spread across a long list of names, and the asking prices change a lot from one to the next. Here is a sample of 96064 land listings from this fall:

Area or road Acreage Asking price
Klamath River Country Estates, Willit Way 2.5 $4,999
Klamath River Country Estates, Greenfinch Way 5 $10,500
Shasta Vista, Norman Drive 2.59 $22,000
Klamath River Country Estates, Trout Court 2.5 $25,000
Big Springs Ranchos, Jade Ave and Quartz Ave 2.6 $47,500
Klamath River Country Estates, Raven Court 4.8 $49,500
High Rd 10.1 $15,000
High Rd 21 $35,000
Ager Beswick Rd 40.88 $65,000
5th Ave E 81.26 $109,000
Ball Mountain Little Shasta Rd 104 $100,000
Little Bogus Creek Rd 22.2 $139,000
Big Springs Rd 40 $170,000
E Louie Rd 720 $450,000

Some Klamath River Country Estates listings carry Hornbrook addresses, so that subdivision shows up in both towns' searches. The table also shows a pattern. The subdivision lots, at about 2.5 acres each, ask more per acre than the open tracts east of town along Ager Beswick, 5th Ave E and Ball Mountain Little Shasta Rd. A 104-acre parcel asking $100,000 comes to under $1,000 an acre. The Big Springs Ranchos lot comes to more than $18,000 an acre.

The homes sell slowly but close to asking

The Montague home market has its own pattern. For the three months ending October 2026, the median sale price in 96064 was $321,835, up 18.6% from the same period a year earlier. Over the same window, Yreka's median sale price was $271,361. Montague looks like the more expensive town until you check price per square foot. For those same three months, Montague homes sold at a median $194 per square foot and Yreka homes at $203.

Over those three months, Montague buyers paid more per home than Yreka buyers and less for each square foot. The higher median is not a per-foot premium for the town.

Those homes take longer to sell. October's median time on market in 96064 was 148 days, up from 111 a year earlier. Yreka's was 82. Once Montague sellers find a buyer, though, they give up less on price. In October, Montague's sale-to-list ratio was 98.2%, compared with 94.3% in Yreka. A second data set puts October discounts at about 2.3% below asking in 96064 and about 3.9% in 96097, so the ranking holds either way.

Small sample sizes explain most of this. Eight sales in a month is not much, and one ranch-style home on acreage can move Montague's median on its own. The California Association of Realtors makes the same point about Siskiyou County as a whole. In September 2026, its countywide median for existing single-family homes was $315,000, with 63 days on market and sales down 33.3% from a year earlier, and the association noted that large swings in small counties can reflect low sales counts. You can read the C.A.R. September 2026 county figures directly. For Montague, the long time on market says buyers are few. The near-full-price sales say the houses that do sell are priced about right.

A low lot price covers only the land

Back to the land. A 2.5-acre lot at $4,999 and a finished rural home at $300,000 or more are both in the same 112 listings, and the cost of turning the first into the second explains much of the price gap.

One pair of listings on the same road shows the size of that gap. On Highway A12 this fall, 11 acres of vacant land asked $36,000, while a manufactured home on 9.07 acres asked $305,000. They are different parcels and can't be compared exactly, but the $269,000 difference between them is the price gap between bare acreage and acreage with a home already on it.

Water. The fee on Siskiyou County's domestic well application is $360. The county also keeps well permits and completion records going back to 1991, so you can look up wells on neighboring parcels. Of the 733 wells recorded in 96064, the median depth is 150 feet. California Well Data estimates that a complete well system in Siskiyou County, with pump, pressure tank and hookup, costs $12,000 to $20,000 at the county's post-2016 median depth of 200 feet. It describes that range as an estimate from published per-foot rates, not a quote for any parcel. Even the low end of that range is more than twice the price of the cheapest Klamath River Country Estates lot.

Power. Electric service varies from lot to lot. One current Klamath River Country Estates listing puts the nearest power pole 200 to 300 yards from the lots and says hookup availability is unknown. Pacific Power's line extension estimator gives only a rough figure for single-family homes, doesn't apply to service inside subdivisions, and leaves out underground trenching. The real number comes from an on-site estimate.

Roads. In these subdivisions, the owners maintain the roads and pay for them through annual dues. According to the Mount Shasta Vista Property Owners Association, the subdivision covers 6.5 square miles: 1,641 parcels of about 2.5 acres each, served by 65 miles of unpaved cinder roads. The lots were first sold in a televised ad campaign in the 1960s. The association's site says annual assessments stand at $300 per parcel and have gone up almost every year since a land rush that began around 2015. A Big Springs Ranchos listing updated in October 2026 lists an $80 annual association fee for its private gravel roads, along with a well on the parcel and an old septic permit for the buyer to verify. The Klamath River Country Estates listing shows $250 per lot per year for road maintenance. Dues change from year to year, so confirm the current figure with each association before you write an offer. The figures in this post are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm the costs for your own parcel with the right professional.

The Big Springs Ranchos lot asks $47,500 for 2.6 acres, nearly ten times the cheapest Willit Way lot, and its listing includes a well on the parcel.

What this means if you're comparing Montague and Yreka

If you want a finished house, Montague's market is about 40 homes deep. On a per-foot basis it isn't more expensive than Yreka, and sellers there have been getting close to asking. A home that has been listed for months may not mean much room to negotiate. In Montague, a long time on market is normal even for homes that end up selling near full price.

If you want land, Montague has far more of it than its size would suggest, and the prices cover a wide range. A cheap subdivision lot and a large tract east of town are different purchases. The lot comes with association roads and dues, and possibly a power line extension. The large tract comes with long distances and fewer neighbors to share costs. Either way, the lot price is the first cost, not the total. For more on pricing and financing, see our guides on how to price rural acreage in Montague and land loans in Montague. For irrigated parcels, our post on water rights near Montague covers the questions to ask before you buy.

A few quick answers

Is Montague's median sale price higher than Yreka's? For the three months ending October 2026, yes: $321,835 in Montague and $271,361 in Yreka. Per square foot, Montague was lower, at $194 compared with $203.

Why are some Montague lots under $10,000? The cheapest lots are about 2.5 acres in older subdivisions such as Klamath River Country Estates. The price covers only the land. Water, power and road dues are separate costs.

Which Montague-area subdivision lots have association road fees? Shasta Vista, Big Springs Ranchos and Klamath River Country Estates all fund road maintenance through owner associations. This fall's figures were $300, $80 and $250 a year respectively, and each one should be confirmed with its association.

If you're weighing a Montague house against a Montague lot, or Montague against Yreka, Sunshine Realty 530 can put a specific parcel's costs next to recent local sales so the comparison is complete before you make an offer. Ask us for a free home valuation and local market review, and we'll go through the numbers for the property you're considering with you.

Work With Us

Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or invest, We're ready to help you achieve your real estate goals with expertise, dedication, and care. Contact us and make your dreams a reality.

.